Learning to Take Losses

Learning to Take Losses By Diego Alcalá There is a very particular feeling that every investor eventually encounters. You open your portfolio or an investment s

By Diego Alcalá · Mon Nov 16 2026 · Investing

Learning to Take Losses

By Diego Alcalá

There is a very particular feeling that every investor eventually encounters. You open your portfolio or an investment statement, see a position in the red, realize that the investment is moving in the opposite direction from what you expected, feel a knot in your stomach, and close it quickly, as though avoiding the sight of a wound. “It will come back. It will rise again. Things will improve,” we tell ourselves. “It is only temporary.” Sometimes that is true. At other times, it can be a symptom of very expensive self-deception.

Learning to take losses is probably the hardest and least taught skill in financial life. Not because it is technically complicated—exiting a position can be as simple as pressing a button—but because it demands something our ego detests: admitting that we were wrong. That is before we even consider the cognitive complexity of changing our minds, acknowledging an error, or doing something counterintuitive. Your original assumption was that the investment would produce a gain, not require you to accept a loss.

When the investment thesis dies

Every investment, at least one made properly, begins with a thesis: a story about why this is going to work. When the facts contradict that story, the thesis dies. Accepting the death of a thesis feels, on a small scale, like grieving. You are letting go of more than money. You are letting go of the version of yourself that was right.

That is the emotional trap. We confuse the asset with our own judgment—identification with the ego reaches places Lao Tzu might never have imagined—and selling at a loss feels like publicly declaring, even if only to ourselves, that we failed. So we cling to the investment. We tell ourselves that until we sell, the loss is “only on paper,” and the story in which we were right remains, technically, alive.

The mistake you do not want to admit

Financial psychology has names for this mechanism. One is the disposition effect: the tendency to sell winners quickly and hold on to losers, the opposite of what would be reasonable, or of what trend theory in technical analysis would suggest. Another is the sunk cost fallacy: remaining in something bad because we have already invested so much, as though money already lost could be recovered simply by holding on longer. But the money you have already put in will not return because of your stubbornness. What you decide today is where to direct the money—and other valuable resources, including your attention and time—that you still have.

George Soros, who built a fortune speculating in financial markets, attributed much of his success to something unglamorous: the speed with which he admitted his mistakes. His point, broadly speaking, was that he was not smarter than everyone else; he recognized his errors sooner. For him, investing well was less about being right than about losing little when he was wrong and gaining much when he was right. Admitting an error quickly was risk management, rather than humiliation.

Temporary volatility or permanent deterioration?

Here I need to apply the brakes, because misunderstood advice to “cut your losses” can be as dangerous as clinging to investments that no longer work. Not every decline means the thesis has died. I have written before that a loss, by itself, does not prove you were wrong. Often it is simply volatility, development time, or temporary noise along the path of a good investment. Selling every time something falls, or fails to move as you would like, is a perfect recipe for crystallizing losses that time might otherwise have healed.

So how do you distinguish an investment that deserves patience from one you should exit? The question is not “How far has the price fallen?” It is “Are the reasons I bought, or entered this particular investment, still alive?” Temporary volatility is a change in price or perceived value; permanent deterioration is a change in fundamentals. If the price has fallen but the thesis remains intact because the business is still sound, the asset is still productive, and the reasons are still there, that is volatility, and holding on is the right response. If what has changed is the reality behind the asset—the business has broken down, the sector has become obsolete, or the debt can no longer be serviced—then this is a dead investment thesis rather than a passing decline. Continuing to hold becomes pride financed with your wealth.

Decide on your exit before you need it

The way to avoid making that decision in a panic is to make it beforehand, calmly. Ideally, for every investment, we should define the conditions under which we would sell. This means identifying a change in fundamentals, rather than simply naming a price. Doing that turns an emotional decision into the execution of a rule that your calmer self wrote down. When exit criteria are established before they are needed, the day those conditions are met is less about deciding than about following your better judgment—or at least the judgment of a version of you that had the time and information necessary to think it through.

Selling at a loss can be the healthiest decision

Selling at a loss is not a failure. Often it is the healthiest decision you can make for your wealth. David Ricardo, another economist and trader, much less controversial than Soros, who also made a fortune in financial markets, expressed the principle as “cut your losses, let your profits run.” Cutting a loss releases capital trapped in a bad idea so that it can be put to work in a better one. That is opportunity cost in practice. The true cost of refusing to sell is more than what you continue to lose: it includes everything that money could be doing elsewhere.

Looking at it differently takes us to a place where the question changes. Instead of asking “How do I recover what I lost in this investment?”—a question that chains you to the past—we ask “Where does my money belong from today onward?” That second question looks forward, which is where money can grow after leaving a less productive investment.

Taking losses maturely is not pessimism. It is recognizing that, in a game involving uncertainty, being wrong is part of the work. The objective is not to avoid every loss. It is to keep any one loss from becoming so large, or so stubborn, that it takes you out of the game. Someone who never learns to lose well will eventually lose everything.

And you: is there an investment you keep carrying because selling it would force you to admit you were wrong, rather than because you still believe in it?

A question for investors looking across borders

For a Canadian or another international investor considering opportunities in the United States, I would bring the discussion back to the same written thesis. What reasons led you to commit capital, what evidence would contradict them, and what conditions did you set for leaving? Investing in another country does not remove the distinction between a disappointing price and a broken investment case. Nor does the effort already spent exploring an opportunity make that opportunity stronger. The useful question remains where your money, attention, and time belong from today onward.

Written by Diego Alcalá, November 16, 2026.

Educational content. This article is not personalized investment advice.

Illustrative photograph: Atlantic Ambience, stock charts, used under the Pexels License.

Read the original Spanish article on Comprando América.

Read on Buying America